Our IGD analysis on the key insights from Exotec’s industry white-paper on warehouse automation.
Grocery supply chains are being asked to deliver greater resilience without compromising efficiency or service. Labour remains difficult and expensive to secure, cost pressure persists and retailers are managing more channels, formats, SKUs and delivery points. Crucially, complexity is rising faster than volume, putting warehouse models built for more predictable flows under pressure. All of which are known challenges within the industry.
IGD Supply Chain has contributed to Exotec’s latest white paper, Grocery Logistics in Transition. It combines IGD’s perspective on the grocery market with academic insight from Professor Matthias Schu at Lucerne University, operational experience from E.Leclerc and Exotec’s automation expertise. Together, these perspectives explore where automation creates value, where the challenges remain and how investment decisions need to evolve.
For supply chain leaders, the question is shifting from whether to automate to what to automate, how far to go and how much flexibility to retain when future volumes, channels and network requirements remain uncertain.
Grocery makes those decisions particularly difficult. Pallets, cases and individual items can pass through the same operation, while ambient, chilled, frozen and fresh products bring different handling requirements. Home delivery, click-and-collect and changing store formats create further variation. The report examines how these challenges play out across e-grocery, fresh produce, store fulfilment and warehouse design.
This broadens the investment case beyond labour savings and productivity. Automation can be assessed against payback periods of up to ten years, during which store estates, channel mix, ranges and volumes can change materially. Leaders therefore need to understand whether capacity can scale, different flows can be accommodated and the operation can adapt without significant further capital.
The implications extend beyond the warehouse. Changes to order profiles, cut-off times, inventory positioning and fulfilment flows affect transport, stores and ultimately customer availability. Automation should therefore be judged on its impact across the network, rather than the efficiency of an individual process.
Integration also becomes critical as automation expands. Exotec highlights the limitations of warehouse management, robotics and planning technologies operating in silos, with greater value coming from the orchestration of receiving, storage, picking, buffering and despatch.
The economics also vary by flow with individual-item picking in e-grocery having different requirements from traditional store replenishment, while fresh produce presents different constraints again. These examples raise one of the report’s most important questions which is where does automation make operational and economic sense, and where does complexity still outweigh the benefit?
The objective is not purely to create a more automated warehouse but it is to create a more productive, resilient and scalable retail network in totality. This aligns closely with IGD’s broader supply chain trends, where technology is increasingly important in managing cost pressure while resilience and flexibility remain fundamental to future supply chain strategy.
For supply chain and innovation leaders considering their next automation investment, four questions stand out for Exotec’s white paper:
Where will our biggest operational and capacity constraints emerge over the next five to ten years?
Which processes genuinely justify automation, and which do not?
Can the solution adapt if assumptions around volumes, channels or formats change?
What value will the investment create across inventory, transport, stores and service, as well as the warehouse?
Grocery Logistics in Transition explores these questions through the economics of
e-grocery automation, the challenges of fresh produce and first-hand experience from E.Leclerc operators, alongside perspectives from IGD, academia and Exotec.
The E.Leclerc experience gives the discussion a particularly practical dimension. At its Seclin drive-through operation, automation increased capacity from 800 to 1,200 orders per day while reducing customer collection waits from up to 15 minutes to below five. It is a tangible example of automation addressing capacity, productivity and service together.
Read the full white-paper; Grocery Logistics in Transition for free on this link, to explore how grocery businesses are approaching the next generation of warehouse automation.